Comparing two Bose headphones, both of which use active technology.

In this posting I’m going to do something I rarely do, which is, something like a product review. I have purchased the following two headphones within the past few months:

  1. Bose QuietComfort 25 Noise Cancelling
  2. Bose AE2 SoundLink

The first set of headphones has an analog 3.5mm stereo input cable, which has a dual-purpose Mike / Headphone Jack, and comes either compatible with Samsung, or with Apple phones, while the second uses Bluetooth to connect to either brand of phone. I should add that the phone I use with either set of headphones is a Samsung Galaxy S9, which supports Bluetooth 5.

The first set of headphones requires a single, AAA alkaline battery to work properly. And this not only fuels its active noise cancelling, but also an equalizer chip that has become standard with many similar middle-price-range headphones. The second has a built-in rechargeable Lithium-Ion Battery, which is rumoured to be good for 10-15 hours of play-time, which I have not yet tested. Like the first, the second has an equalizer chip, but no active noise cancellation.

I think that right off the bat I should point out, that I don’t approve of this use of an equalizer chip, effectively, to compensate for the sound oddities of the internal voice-coils. I think that more properly, the voice-coils should be designed to deliver the best frequency response possible, by themselves. But the reality in the year 2019 is, that many headphones come with an internal equalizer chip instead.

What I’ve found is that the first set of headphones, while having excellent noise cancellation, has two main drawbacks:

  • The jack into which the analog cable fits, is poorly designed, and can cause bad connections,
  • The single, AAA battery can only deliver a voltage of 1.5V, and if the actual voltage is any lower, either because a Ni-MH battery was used in place of an alkaline cell, or, because the battery is just plain low, the low-voltage equalizer chip will no longer work fully, resulting in sound that reveals the deficiencies in the voice-coil.

The second set of headphones overcomes both these limitations, and I fully expect that its equalizer chips will have uniform behaviour, that my ears will be able to adjust to in the long term, even when I use them for hours or days. Also, I’d tend to say that the way the equalizer arrangement worked in the first set of headphones, was not complete in fulfilling its job, even when the battery was fully charged. Therefore, If I only had the money to buy one of the headphones, I’d choose the second set, which I just received today.

But, having said that, I should also add that I have two 12,000BTU air conditioners running in the Summer months, which really require the noise-cancellation of the first set of headphones, that the second set does not provide.

Also, I have an observation of why the EQ chip in the second set of headphones may work better than the similarly purposed chip in the first set…

(Updated 9/28/2019, 19h05 … )

Continue reading Comparing two Bose headphones, both of which use active technology.

Overheated Circuitry

One of the things which I do frequently, is ‘walk around’, or, ‘use public transit’, with my disposable earphones plugged in to my Samsung Galaxy S9 Smart-Phone, and listening to music. These earphones are clearly not the ones, which had the AKG seal of approval, and which shipped with the phone. But this week-end marks the second heat-wave this Summer, when outside daytime temperatures exceeded 31⁰C, with direct sunlight and not a cloud in the sky. And under those conditions, the battery of my phone starts to hit a temperature of 42⁰. One of the facts which I know is, that Lithium-Ion batteries like the one in my phone do not tolerate temperatures exceeding 41⁰C.

A peculiar behaviour which has set in for the second time, during this second heat-wave of the season, is that the music I was listening to would either back-space to the beginning of the song, or skip ahead one song, or just stop. So, a catastrophic sort of explanation I could think of would be, that the entire phone, with its battery, is finally just having a meltdown. But, a second possibility exists, that merely the chip in the earphone-cord could be malfunctioning. After all, the little pod in the earphone-cord has one button and a mike, and it’s actually cheaper to mass-produce the chip that makes it work, than it would be to mass-produce other sorts of discrete components. One cheap chip could just be malfunctioning in the extreme heat, and not the entire, complex circuitry of the phone. (:1)

The earphones cost me about $15, while the phone is much more expensive than that.

But even if it was true, that only the little remote-control in the earphone-cord was malfunctioning, this can lead to impractical situations, because just random patterns, of unreal button-press-combinations, could also send the software of my phone into a confused state, and even so, if the circuitry in the smart-phone never malfunctioned. This behaviour could get misinterpreted by the security apps of the phone, let’s say, as though somebody had ripped the earphone-cord off my head, and thrown all my possessions around.

All that was really happening was that my music was no longer playing, as I was walking home normally, in the heat, with my overheated electronics. And when I got home, my actual phone never displayed any signs of having malfunctioned.

(Updated 8/17/2019, 17h50 … )

Continue reading Overheated Circuitry

Some observed progress in Lithium-Ion Batteries.

I have posted before about Lithium-Ion batteries. My relatively new Samsung Galaxy S9 Smart-Phone possesses one, and seems to have better battery performance overall, than my old Galaxy S6 did. Also, both these phones had a sensor chip which measures battery voltage. I use an Android app called GSam Battery Monitor Pro, to get occasional glimpses of what my battery is doing, and without such a hardware chip, the app would not be able to provide meaningful information. On my Galaxy S9 phone, the battery has a voltage of ~4.2V once fully charged, and I’m assuming that to plug the phone in just keeps it connected to a constant voltage source…


On my previous, Galaxy S6, when fully charged, the battery had a voltage of ‘only’ ~3.7V. And so one strategy which Samsung could be using to increase battery life, would simply be to charge the same battery technology to a higher voltage. However, usually, doing so would only result in the battery catching fire. And so, some improvement in the actual design of the battery had to take place, so that it could be kept charged to 4.2V, and not suffer any immediate damage.



Dolby Atmos

My new Samsung Galaxy S9 smart-phone exceeds the audio capabilities of the older S-series phones, and the sound-chip of this one has a feature called “Dolby Atmos”. Its main premise is, that a movie may have had audio encoded according to either Dolby Atmos, or according to the older, analog ‘Pro Logic’ system, and that, using headphone spatialization, it can be played back with more or less correct positioning. Further, the playback of mere music can be made more rich.

(Updated 11/25/2018, 13h30 … )

Rather than just to write that this feature exists and works, I’m going to use whatever abilities I have to analyze the subject, and to try to form an explanation of how it works.

In This earlier posting, I effectively wrote the (false) supposition, that sound compression which works in the frequency domain, fails to preserve the phase position of the signal correctly. I explained why I thought so.

But in This earlier posting, I wrote what the industry had done in practice, which can result in the preservation of phase-positions, of frequency components.

The latter of the above two postings is the more-accurate. What follows from that is, that if the resolution of the compressed stream is high, meaning that the quantization step is small, phase position is likely to be preserved well, while if the resolution (of the sound) is poor, meaning that the quantization step is large, and the resulting integers small, poor phase information will also result, that may be so poor as only to observe the ±180⁰ difference that also follows, from recorded, non-zero coefficients being signed values.

‘Dolby Atmos’ is a multi-track movie sound system, that encodes actual speaker positions, but, not based on the outdated Pro Logic boxes, which were based on analog wires coming in. In order to understand what was done with Pro Logic, maybe the reader should also read This earlier posting of mine, which explains some of the general principles. In addition, while Pro Logic 1 and 2 had as outputs, physical speakers, Dolby Atmos on the S9 aims to use headphone spatialization, to achieve a similar effect.

I should also state from the beginning, that the implementation of Dolby Atmos in the Samsung S9 phone, allows the user to select between three modes when active:

  1. Movies,
  2. Music,
  3. Voice.

In addition to the actual surround decoding, the Samsung S9 changes the equalizer settings – yes, it also has a built-in equalizer.

(Updated 11/30/2018, 7h30 … )

Continue reading Dolby Atmos